Disciplined in Sophisticated Defense and Insurance Litigation

SPOTLIGHT| Doug Berry | The Veterans Consortium Pro Bono Program

In your most recent pro bono case, you were able to get the decision of the Board of Veterans’ Appeals reversed on behalf of your client. Is that correct?

Yes.  Case was remanded back to the Board of Veterans’ Appeals (“BVA”) for further proceedings which is considered a victory; only on very rare occasions does the court actually award monetary benefits as part of a favorable decision. 

Briefly, virtually all of the records of his military service were lost.  What government records were available showed his discharge from the Army was “under other than honorable conditions.”  Since he was also AWOL for one or more extended periods of time (total 900+ days) after he returned from Viet-Nam (where he served honorably in the 101st Airborne as an infantryman), the BVA made the assumption at least one absence was in excess of 180 consecutive days which, under the law, precluded benefits.   The client, however, was in possession of original certificates of discharge (bearing the raised seal of the National Archives, which the VA views as conclusive evidence) which, because his records had been lost, he was understandably reticent to entrust his originals to the VA; however, the record demonstrated that he had offered to show them personally to the VA at one of its offices in New York City on more than one occasion.  The VA concluded the purported original discharge certificates submitted were not worthy of belief because they (copies of his originals) lacked the raised seal of the National Archives.   The VA has a statutory duty to assist a veteran with his or her claim.  The Court found that more assistance, in the form of a personal inspection of the original documents, could have been provided.  Additionally, inasmuch as the records of the exact dates and duration of his AWOLs were lost, the VA could not prove any single absence was longer than 180 days’ duration.  On remand, the BVA is to address these issues. 

Can you explain how your client’s claim for VA benefits got to the Court of Appeals for Veterans Claims?

He originally applied for a home loan guarantee in 2002 (!). Shortly thereafter, he also applied for compensation for diabetes mellitus based on exposure to Agent Orange, both of which were denied.  The VA has adopted a presumption that anyone who served either in-country or in the rivers or contiguous coastal waters of Viet-Nam has been exposed to Agent Orange and any of several enumerated diseases such diabetes and several types of cancer are presumed to be “service connected” as a result of that exposure and entitled to compensation, provided his or her service met minimal other criteria, one of which is that his or her discharge not be based on an unauthorized absence of 180 days or longer.  In 2007 (before my involvement), the Court remanded the case back to the BVA for additional proceedings, mainly to have the Army further research its records.  It was then returned to the Court in late 2011 with an unfavorable decision which is when I was asked to assist. Thirteen years later he really doesn’t need the home loan guarantee; therefore, this case is about monetary compensation for diabetes, presumably caused by exposure to Agent Orange, in the form of a disability rating and pension.

How did you come to be involved in the claim?

An Annapolis classmate and fellow Marine Corps officer and lawyer friend of mine became assistant general counsel to the Paralyzed Veterans of America when he retired from the Marine Corps (he is now the Chief Judge of  the Court of Appeals for Veterans Claims).  PVA is one of several veterans’ service organizations (e.g., VFW, American Legion, National Veterans Legal Services Project) that formed the Veterans’ Consortium and its pro bono program. He helped organize the Consortium and recruited me around 1994 to assist on a pro bono basis.

Can any lawyer provide services to a veteran with a claim before the VA, Board of Veterans’ Appeals or Court of Appeals for Veterans Claims?

Yes. You have to be a member of the CAVC Bar but there is no exam or prerequisite other than be duly licensed in a state or the District of Columbia and pay the fee.   However, in order to practice before the VA or BVA, one must be “accredited” by the VA’s General Counsel, 38 U.S.C. §5901.  I have enlisted a lawyer who specializes in work before the BVA to assume his representation before the BVA.

What is the most difficult part of handling the pro bono appeals?

The area can be incredibly arcane and complex.   Fortunately, the Consortium provides the attorney with copies of statutes, rules and regulations governing the VA as well as a detailed manual explaining the process with case citations.   The two books together, soft cover, are probably 4-5” thick and over 1000 pp each.  The Consortium provides a review of issues of possible merit and a “mentor” who is a full-time veterans law practitioner in Washington with whom you can consult and get advice.

You are a retired Marine Corps Officer.  What impact has your own experience as an officer and Judge Advocate had on your pro bono work on behalf of veterans?

In many respects, I know everyone of these guys, having served with and alongside them in Viet-Nam and elsewhere.  With respect to veterans of more recent conflicts, I knew their fathers and uncles; the names and faces change but the nature of their selfless service and commitment to the country and to each other don’t.  They don’t ask for much and for me, it’s not too much to try to apply some special skills in order to attempt to help them. 

 On the technical side, I know the administrative and judicial side of the military.  I saw hundreds of men return, get lost in the society they returned to and get caught on the wrong side of the process; I know how and why many of them ended up as they did.  Mistakes are made: Witness the lost records.  It’s not too late to try to help those who served in Viet-Nam and as they age, we’re about to experience a tsunami of veterans from Iraq and Afghanistan, many with devastating injuries which would have been fatal in earlier conflicts.  Sadly, this is a growth industry.

Butler donates any recoveries it makes for fees under the Equal Access to Justice Act.  How long has Butler done that and what prompted the decision to do so?

The Equal Access to Justice Act (“EAJA”) 28 U.S.C. §2412(d), provides that if you prevail in asserting a claim against the U.S. Government for taking  a position which was not “substantially justified,” the successful litigant is entitled to a reasonable attorney fee.  Among the decisions which may not be “substantially justified,” is a denial of benefits.  EAJA was legislatively applied to the CAVC in 1992, thereby overruling Lincoln-era legislation which limited fees for assisting a veteran to $5.00 (later raised to $10.00) and opening the way for meaningful assistance to those with meritorious claims.

As a condition for representation, the Consortium requires the veteran client assign to his or her counsel the right to any fee which might be awarded.  Having prevailed in that a remand for further proceedings was obtained, we were entitled to a reasonable fee (there is a very complex formula which adjusts fees based on locale and a 1996 statutory benchmark with produces the current figure $200.14/hour for attorneys in the Tampa/St. Petersburg area).  We negotiated the fee claim to $10,000 and donated it back to the Consortium.  This is the fourth or fifth time we have won at CAVC and donated the fee.  It only seems appropriate since we undertook the assignment “pro bono” – that is, without the expectation of a fee.  The fee was a windfall and the donation allows the Consortium to continue its good work.

What would you recommend lawyers do to get involved in pro bono work for veterans?

Recognize it’s a significant commitment – The Record Before the Agency was over 540 pages and I had over 60 hours in this over about 16 months – in an area most know little or nothing about unless they participated in a veterans’ law clinic in law school (several are popping up in schools now). Thus, it can be frustrating in that you don’t know what you don’t know but you do know there are about 2000 pages of manuals and statutes, etc., you haven’t fully assimilated.

Be sure the program provides a mentor or other experienced practitioner to oversee and assist. Just because it’s pro bono, doesn’t mean you are exempt from a malpractice claim.

SPOTLIGHTKind Acts through Community Service: Telisha Thompson

A records management clerk who has been with the firm just under a year explains that when she is not at Butler, she loves serving the community.  In 2009, Telisha joined a prominent organization called the Jerusalem Grand Chapter Order of the Eastern Star. She is a part of the Lola Simon Chapter where she dons all white at meetings and is known as an Associate Matron.

Read More »
SPOTLIGHTPatrick Malley | Oh No! Anime

Our newest Butler Spotlight features IT Assistant, Patrick Malley, who gives us insight into the world of Anime. Patrick runs a successful Anime blog and Podcast, as well as attends conferences and speaks at panels where he shares his expertise.

Read More »
SPOTLIGHTJohn Garaffa Earns Veterans Network Meritorious Service Award!

Butler Weihmuller Katz Craig is proud to announce that Partner John Garaffa, earned the Veterans Network Meritorious Service Award for his active duty service and post-service pro bono legal work on behalf of veterans. 

Read More »
SPOTLIGHTButler Trades in Blue For Pink to Promote Breast Cancer Awareness

“Butler has been my second family for 15 years. I think Butler has a lot of great things they support, and I am so happy Breast Cancer is one of them. My coworkers have given me so much encouragement,” said Sandra.

Read More »
SPOTLIGHTGerald "Jerry" Albrecht Speaks on Flood Insurance for Bay News 9

Butler Weihmuller Katz Craig is excited to announce that Partner Gerald “Jerry” Albrecht was selected to appear on Chris Ingram and Allen Clendenin’s Common Ground segment on Bay News 9 to speak about flood insurance.  The segment aired on Sunday, September 18th at 11 a.m. and also at 8 p.m.

Read More »
SPOTLIGHTButler Believes in Giving Back

Butler and its employees has proudly provided over 400 children with backpacks filled to the brim with school supplies for Metropolitan Ministries' Backpacks for Hope. Serving our community’s future generation by donating essential educational resources is of the utmost importance to our Firm.

Read More »
SPOTLIGHTZach Jett | Locked Up for Charity

“My grandfather was diagnosed with this disease later on in his life…and it really affected his mobility. He was very active his whole life, so it was very frustrating for him. It really spoke to me personally.”

Read More »
SPOTLIGHTAmerican Civil Liberties Union

I came to see that it was a lot more complex than that, that they were actually protecting the rights themselves from being slowly eroded away, and standing up for people was one of several ways to do that. It was thankless-but-essential work, and it impressed me that there were people doing it for no reason other than that they thought it should be done.

Read More »
SPOTLIGHTKatelyn Desrosiers, Jacob Hanson & Dining with Dignity

The last time I volunteering, I was talking to a woman who was there with her toddler.  I asked her if she came to the Café often.  She responded that she does not come very often, but when money gets tight at the end of the month, she visits the Café to provide a meal for her and her son.

Read More »
SPOTLIGHTMichelle Green | Fashion Blog

I have always loved fashion and after seeing so many fashion bloggers on Instagram posting their amazing looks and where to get them, I was inspired to start my own blog.  I have been posting and blogging for about 9 months.

Read More »
SPOTLIGHTDiane Barnes-Reynolds | Arctic Adventure

I know it sounds crazy. Everyone I told laughed. They thought it was a joke because of the extraordinarily cold weather at the Arctic Circle. But when you live in the paradise that is Tampa, where else would you go? And it was quite an amazing adventure. I only regret that we couldn’t take our daughter; and I can’t wait until we return when she’s old enough to join us. In the meantime...

Read More »
SPOTLIGHTScott Frank | El Camino de Santiago de Compostela

The trip was to Spain for the purpose of completing a pilgrimage called El Camino de Santiago de Compostela, which translated means The Way of St. James. It refers to St. James the Greater, one of the apostles of Jesus. There are 10 different routes of the Camino, with the most popular being the Camino Frances or the French Way. This Camino starts in St. Jean Pied de Port, just over the French side of the France-Spain border...

Read More »
SPOTLIGHTGloria Arthur & Makitia Dillard | Guardian ad Litem

For those who are not familiar, the Florida Guardian ad Litem program (GAL) is voluntary and is set up to provide an effective voice for Florida's neglected, abused and abandoned children. The program works in conjunction with the Circuit Courts. Florida law defines GAL as the person, "who is appointed by the court to represent the best interests of a child in a proceeding as provided for by law … 

Read More »
SPOTLIGHTLewis Collins | Making of a Modern Day Knight

I was asked to be a mentor for a friend’s son who was going through a program with his dad 20 years ago called the “Making of a Modern Day Knight.” To act as his mentor, I had to read the book that this program  was based on and learn the way to raise a son as God expects — so the world doesn’t craft a son’s image of what it is to be a “man.” I was very impressed with this program and, when my son was born 3 years later, I promised myself (and him) that we would go through this program together...

Read More »
SPOTLIGHTCurt Allen & Brian Hohman | Little League

I like to make safety and fun a priority. Unfortunately, some coaches and parents take a “win at all costs” approach. I believe this misses the point entirely and sends the wrong message to the kids. Instead of giving them a break from everyday pressures, it adds more. I played many sports as a kid, and played football at the collegiate level. Hence, I understand competition and a desire to win. But, at the little league level...

Read More »
SPOTLIGHT"Al" Harrington Smoot | CCYS

Al works with the Capital City Youth Services (CCYS) which provides shelter and counseling for at-risk young people, including runaways, ages 10 to 17. CCYS is the only shelter for this age group in Leon County and the seven surrounding counties. CCYS also provides counseling, free of charge to families struggling with issues relating to teenagers. CCYS offers teenagers a "time out" so they can either work out their issues, or get out of a dangerous home environment...

Read More »
SPOTLIGHTAaron Jacobs | Fight Night Productions

I was first introduced to boxing when I watched a Bernard Hopkins (at that time, the Middleweight World Champion) fight in high school. I was fascinated with the sport, and from that point forward, was consumed with learning as much about boxing as possible. I would read books, magazines, and watch as much boxing as i could. In college, I started the Florida State University Boxing Club, which was part of the Sports Club Council. We ran a small amateur program for a handful of students out of a boxing gym...

Read More »
SPOTLIGHTPeter Vogt | Addis Abba, Ethiopia

The project involved working at a relatively new school located on the outskirts of Addis Abba. The school did not have a library, proper sanitary facilities, or any playing fields. There were 17 people on our team, and we worked with an Ethiopian crew. The school has approximately 1200 students, and thee children were on site at lunch/recess. This was a very big project and we had limited tools. For instance, we hand mixed cement for the foundations, and we completed an outdoor basketball court and volleyball court...

Read More »
SPOTLIGHTRick Mulder | JDRF

I became involved with Juvenile Diabetes Research Foundation (JDRF) when my son Garrett was diagnosed with juvenile diabetes in August of 2008.  Each year, more than 15,000 children and 15,000 adults - approximately 80 people per day - are diagnosed with type 1 diabetes (T1D) in the U.S. It comes on suddenly, causes dependence on injected or pumped insulin for life, and carries the constant threat...

Read More »
SPOTLIGHTPaul Butler | Manaleni

There are approximately 100 kids served at the Manaleni Center, located about 50 miles northeast of Pretoria.  A team visits the kids and staff at least once a year.   From day one we have committed to do more than write checks.  We know the kids and they know us.  They remember us.  They know us by name and we know them by name.  One year there was a team member who had been on the two previous...

Read More »